I saw
The Reader on Monday which, apart from the obvious appeal of much Kate Winslet nudity, posed some interesting questions. Her character's illiteracy was used as a metaphor for people's lack of knowledge about the Holocaust, and started the rusty old gears of my brain turning in a particular direction.
To what extent are those of a particular religion, race or minority obliged to be spokespeople for that group or culture? Several of my online correspondents are Jewish, and one or two of them have a deep interest in matters relating to the Holocaust. I wonder how much of this is due their own family history or a "shared" memory of something that had a disastrous effect on others of the same faith?
Similarly, many women, gay people and those of other races or religions have fought for recognition and equality through the years. Should those who come after them feel a duty to carry on the struggle even if they don't have any direct experience of the discrimination or prejudice their forebears suffered?
I ask this as someone with a disability who's been lucky enough not to have to spend my whole life thinking of myself as disabled. It's a part of who I am, yes, but it doesn't define me. I went to school with several kids who grew up into the sort of people who defined themselves by what they weren't and, as a result, were encouraged to have no higher ambitions than to become statistics.
I saw even more of this during the years I "worked" as an advocate for people with disabilities. Yes, you're entitled to this payment, that subsidy or whatever, but is that really all you want? My enthusiasm and idealism for the job evaporated very quickly because I couldn't relate to many of the situations I had to deal with. I could empathise as easily as the next guy, but I felt like a hypocrite because I'd never experienced any grave social injustices first hand. Or maybe I had, I just chose not to let it bring me down. Sure I can't get up stairs and I'd need a referral from a social worker if I ever wanted to use a dating service, but so what? Neither of those things bug me enough to make me want to change the world single handed. I can't speak for everyone who has a disability because I have no right or reason to. That sort of thing is better left to people who have a true passion for their cause, whatever it may be.
Having waded through all that, you could well ask if I believe in anything. Like the song says, "I believe in me" and I believe in the power of stories to give us the strength we need to get through everyday life in one piece. That's as close to a credo or manifesto as I'll ever get and, while it won't win any community service medals, it's enough for me. Peace out.